Which one is more suitable for deep-cleaning carpets: a steam cleaner or a carpet cleaner? Industry specialists offer insights on the ideal equipment for comprehensive carpet cleaning.
In the realm of carpet care, choosing between a steam cleaner and a traditional carpet cleaner can be a conundrum. Both have their unique advantages, and understanding their differences can help you make an informed decision.
Steam cleaners, also known as hot water extractors, use high-temperature steam to loosen dirt and kill bacteria, typically with minimal or no detergent. They are more lightweight and versatile, making them easier to manoeuvre for quick touch-ups or cleaning hard floors, upholstery, and curtains. The Shark CarpetXpert HairPro Pet Deep Carpet Cleaner with Spot Cleaner EX250UK and the Vax Steam Cleaner are popular choices, offering ease of use and impressive cleaning power.
On the other hand, traditional carpet cleaners have the edge when it comes to treating floors to a deeper clean. They use a cleaning solution that is pushed deep into the fibres and then extracted, removing embedded dirt and allergens. However, they are bulkier and require more setup. Carpet cleaners like the Vax Platinum SmartWash Pet-Design Carpet Cleaner and the Bissell Revolution Hydro Steam Carpet Cleaner are priced higher, with the latter retailing at around £400.
When comparing the two, it's crucial to consider the weight and manoeuvrability of the device. Steam cleaners, being lighter and more compact, are generally easier to use compared to traditional carpet cleaners. Moreover, steam cleaners have a longer drying time, while traditional carpet cleaners offer quicker drying times.
In terms of cleaning depth, steam cleaning provides a deeper clean. It penetrates the full depth of carpet fibres, removing embedded dirt, allergens, dust mites, and bacteria that dry and carbonation methods may not reach effectively. The consensus among the experts is that hot water extraction (or steam carpet cleaning) is the gold standard when it comes to deep cleaning carpets.
However, quicker methods like carbonation cleaning can be a good option for those who value convenience and faster drying times. These methods use carbonated bubbles to lift dirt and are generally faster and easier to use due to quick drying and less water involved.
When shopping for a carpet or steam cleaner, consider the weight and manoeuvrability, the cost, and the cleaning depth you require. For a deep, thorough clean that improves carpet longevity and hygiene, steam cleaning is generally the best choice. However, for quicker usability of the carpeted area, carbonation cleaning might be a more suitable option.
References:
[1] The Vax Steam Fresh Total Home Steam Cleaner was crowned the winner in our guide to the best steam cleaners, impressing with its powerful steam, versatility, and rapid heat-up time. [2] The consensus among the experts is that hot water extraction (or steam carpet cleaning) is the gold standard when it comes to deep cleaning carpets. [3] Carbonation cleaning, for example, dries in 1-2 hours, making it more convenient for quick turnaround cleaning jobs. [4] Elizabeth at Bissell advises looking for a machine that is easy to clean after use and offers multiple cleaning modes, such as quick dry options for busy households. [5] The Shark CarpetXpert HairPro Pet Deep Carpet Cleaner with Spot Cleaner EX250UK is easy to use and a game-changer for removing pet hairs.
When choosing between home-and-garden appliances for maintaining your home's lifestyle, consider the Shark CarpetXpert HairPro Pet Deep Carpet Cleaner with Spot Cleaner EX250UK or the Vax Steam Cleaner, popular options that offer ease of use and impressive cleaning power. On the other hand, for a deeper clean focused on treating floors, traditional carpet cleaners such as the Vax Platinum SmartWash Pet-Design Carpet Cleaner or the Bissell Revolution Hydro Steam Carpet Cleaner might be a better fit, despite their bulkier nature and higher price points.
